Updated 100 year old Oatmeal Cookie Recipe

This week I received my confirmation from University of South Alabama Archaeology Department that the archaeology dig would occur on Saturday. Mother Nature was cooperating. Months ago, I had signed up as a volunteer to aid USA during their active archaeological project at Old St. Stephens on the Globe Hotel circa 1815-1822.

Wooden area on main street where buildings, homes were located in a once thriving community www.diningwithmimi.com
Wooden area on main street where buildings, homes were located in a once thriving community

Eager to assist and happy when I received the email from Bonnie Gums confirming the dig. Although on Friday while making preparations for my early departure, I wondered what I agreed to. The dig started at 9am and it was in Washington County. My challenge was  the 90 minute drive on a “perfect day to paddle”.

Ready to “dig in the dirt”?

I have never volunteered for a dig nor did  I know anything about the site. Books I had read often had archaeology woven throughout the pages. Movies often have this topic as the focus. During the day I did not expect, Indiana Jones drama at the site. I was a volunteer showing up, to aid as needed.

Site of Globe Hotel near where I was digging and atUpdated 100 year old Oatmeal Cookie Recipe www.diningwithmimi.com
Site of Globe Hotel
A ghost town and long winding road

While leaving Baldwin County, the scenery changes from busy city, waterfront Port to deep countryside landscapes and hidden away chemical plants. Of course you see small towns tucked away in rural landscapes. At the end of my journey was a small  ghost town called Old St. Stephens. An old river town with a past that included  the following:

-site of Spanish Fort circa 1790
-Choctaw Trading Post 1803
-Federal Land office
-Alabama’s  first Territorial capital and beginning
-in 1818 it had 400-500 buildings many of stone and a population of several thousands (three times the size of Mobile)
-an old curse of Pioneer Minister Lorenzo Dow

In 1819, Alabama became a state and the capital was relocated from St. Stephens to Cahaba.   Invention of shallow draft paddle wheelers bringing goods up river created a negative outcome for St. Stephens.  Bypassed by improved trade routes thereby reducing traffic and commerce. With the government and revenue opportunities leaving, the town started to decline. Yellow Fever ravaged the area in the 1820’s and completed the downhill spiral.

Historical Society formed in 1890

This almost ghost town, had a guardian angel in the  citizens of  new St. Stephens which had formed down the road. They formed in 1890 and maintained a Historical Society to protect and keep their history.

Fast forward many years, a private company  built a rock quarry near the old town and local residents of New St Stephens recognized the potential threat that it could have on the Old site. In 1988, the Alabama legislature created the St. Stephens Historical Commission by Act Number 88-335.

This assisted in ensuring the history could be preserved for the future. Dig site is a great place to do archaeology work. It had not developed after everyone moved away and was hidden away awaiting discovery.

Sign for deivery of St Stephens Updated 100 year old Oatmeal Cookie Recipe www.diningwithmimi.com
St Stephens Lake sign
Historical Park and amenities

In 2000, the Old St. Stephens Historical Park opened. St Stephens site is in a quiet hideaway filled with natures beauty. Historical Park has a 100 acre aquamarine lake including a beach. Park rents canoes and kayaks. Sixteen miles of hiking and  horse riding trails are available. RV hookups and primitive camp sites for overnight guests.

Tools for the day www.diningwithmimi.com
Tools for the day

I glanced at the view, on my way to the dig but did not research the amenities of the place. The beauty of the area is protected. It is unspoiled by large crowds but it looks primitive.

Large Scoops used in digging process where I ate Updated 100 year old Oatmeal Cookie Recipe
Large Scoops
Time to Dig

Truly, I enjoyed my day spent with archaeologist’s George Shorter and Frank. They have been working on this site for a long time and have started discovering some of the mystery to this old ghost town. George was patient and gave me instructions for how to use the tools to “dig” my assigned area.

Screen for dirt and artifact separation www.diningwithmimi.com Updated 100 year old Oatmeal Cookie Recipe
Screen for dirt and artifact separation

Then transport the “dirt and such” to the screening area to screen and separate the artifacts. Artifacts are then brought back then  cataloged later by the archaeology lab. Then the lab will wash, inspect, name, label and submit for review.

Updated 100 year old Oatmeal Cookie Recipe that I brought to Site dig located next to hotel www.diningwithmimi.com
Site dig located next to hotel

During the day, a Boy Scout Troupe  showed up to view and “dig”the site. A family of four spent the afternoon “digging in the dirt” along side me. The five-year old looked like he was having a great time. What a great outing for a family to spend time together in nature, preserving our history.

Cellar of former hotel for dig Updated 100 year old Oatmeal Cookie Recipe www.diningwithmimi.com
Cellar of hotel

George and Frank are devoted to this work and it is apparent.  Yet at this site, mysteries are waiting. If you have any interest in becoming a volunteer contact Bonnie Gums at USA,  bgums@southalabama.edu.  The digs take place once a month starting in the Fall.

A sign in the protected Unlawful to disturb St Stephens www.diningwithmimi.com
A sign in the protected area
No one shows up empty handed

Of course, on Friday afternoon prior to my “dig departure”, I decided that I should bring cookies to the site as well. It is never good to show up empty-handed. I researched cookie recipes and adapted a 100-year-old recipe. I hope that you enjoy them.

Updated 100 year old Oatmeal Cookie Recipe baked and ready to eat at Old St. Stephens www.dinignwithmimi.com
Old St. Stephens Cookie


Old St. Stephens Oatmeal Cookies
Serves 3-4 dozen depending on size

1/2 cup butter room temperature
1 3/4 cup sugar
2 Eggs
2 Tablespoons Molasses
1 cup Oatmeal
2 1/2 cup All-purpose flour
1 Teaspoon Double Acting Baking Powder
1 1/2 cups trail mix (goji berries, cranberries, walnuts, cashews, coconut chips, pumpkin seeds)
1/2 cup pecans, chopped

Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Grease baking tray.

Updated 100 year old Oatmeal Cookie Recipe Cookie Dough with great red scoop www.diningwithmimi.com
Cookie Dough with great scoop

In mixing bowl add the butter and sugar and blend. Drop one egg at a time and blend. Blend in the molasses, then oatmeal ,then all-purpose flour and baking powder. Remove from mixer and fold in trail mix and chopped pecans.

Depress on Updated 100 year old Oatmeal Cookie Recipe to flatten slightly www.diningwithmimi.com
Depress on cookie to flatten slightly

Use a cookie scoop and drop on baking tray. With a fork depress slightly on the cookie. Bake cookies for 8-10 minutes. Transfer to a cooling rack. The cookies have a chewy texture.

Cooking rack of Updated 100 year old Oatmeal Cookie Recipe www.diningwithmimi.com
cookies cooling on rack

 In summary at the end of the day, I was way past tired.  Finally, it was time for me to drive back to Fairhope but it gave me time to think about history. Join USA in their efforts to preserve and protect, it is a day well spent.


Recipe Adapted from “The Lions Club Cookbook
Billie Joe Stanley and Lion Joe Stanley







Author: Mimi

I have a love affair with food, entertaining, travel and music. www.diningwithmimi.com is a vehicle for me to share my journey of food, travel and music. Traveling allows exposure to all types of foods and flavors. I have learned to cook by being hungry, curious and willing to fail. Food is another form of art and creative expression. Join me on my journey. Copyright 2016-2019 by Mimi

11 thoughts on “Updated 100 year old Oatmeal Cookie Recipe”

  1. I sampled the watermelon martinis last night…they were wonderfully refreshing! Not too sweet and just enough kick….and I have to say they were a perfect pairing to the oatmeal cookies!! Delish! Can’t wait to make them!

  2. Mimi,
    Enjoy your site very much… and enjoy being your food guinea pig. I think I gained 15 pounds since you started cooking these posted recipes.

Please let me know thoughts about the site.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.